Critics Page
Radical Vulnerability
I’ve often written and spoken about what I call “radical vulnerability.” I originally came across the term in an essay by theorist Gavatri Spivak. I’m not sure what she meant by it, but to me it means making myself as vulnerable in my work as an artist is in their work. It means not taking pot shots at sitting ducks or the weak; not just ratifying the inevitable; it means trying to deliver up as much as my real opinion about something as possible—even when I am thinking things I don’t want to think. It means trying to be conscious of the multiple sub-strata of the experience and knowledge of others. It means being alert to things that jar me so much that they alter my reality.
Recently my internal compass was reset while reading Richard Ellmann’s extraordinary biography Oscar Wilde.Until this book I thought that no one had ever had more psychic pain inflicted on them than the characters in Proust who suffer endless internal agonies and obsessions. No one has ever made jealousy so palpably viscous and terrifying. Reading Ellmann’s horrifying account of the psychic and physical brutalities inflicted by England on Oscar Wilde make what Proust did look almost tame. Great Britain subjected Wilde to multiple trials for “indecent acts,” public humiliation and abuse, and a petrifying two years of being incarcerated at hard labor in three different prisons each more hideous and barbaric than the last.
While in jail, Wilde, perhaps the most loquacious person who ever lived, was not permitted to speak a word. Ever. For two years. Perpetually starved and underfed, when he was fed it left him simultaneously malnourished and suffering from non-stop dysentery and diarrhea. English prisons did not have plumbing as officials feared inmates might “speak” through tapping on pipes. Each prisoner was given only a tin cup and forced to sleep in his own feces. Wilde’s bed was a narrow, upwardly inclined wooden plank set an inch or so from the cold stone floor. He had no mattress or blanket and so suffered the further torment of permanent insomnia. Pen, pencil, ink, and paper were not permitted. His prison number was C.3.3. Each week prisoners were allowed only 15 minutes outside their solitary confinement. During these 15 minutes they were forced to walk in circles within an enclosed brick courtyard. Once, another prisoner spoke to Wilde, saying, “your sort” shouldn’t have to suffer this kind of punishment. It was the first pity Wilde experienced in more than a year. He began to weep, said, “God bless you,” and was punished for doing so. He was released from prison a broken old man, having served every single day of his sentence. He died two years later at the age of 46.
The “radical vulnerability” of reading this made me realize that any society that breaks a person in prison is itself broken. I have never looked upon jail sentences or prison life, let alone the American prison system, the same way. Ellmann imparted an infinitesimal bit of Wilde’s human vulnerability. He opened me. I am cut to the quick with more than just pity, pain, and rage. I experience this as more than merely philosophical, abstract, and ideological. I am shaken to the core and changed by it.
Contributor
Jerry Saltz
RECOMMENDED ARTICLES

J.C. Hallman with Lydia Moland
JUNE 2023 | Books
Hallman has also embedded Anarchas story in gloriously rich detail from the nineteenth century, ranging from comet showers to train derailments to international espionage in the court of Louis Napoleon. That panorama alone makes the book a riveting read. But despite the scope and the glitter, Hallman never allows us to lose sight of Anarcha: her exploitation, her humanity, the embodied Black womanhood that left her so exposed to others whims and schemes. Hallmans novelistic writing and brisk pacing had me eagerly turning pages, alternately aghast at and elevated by this story of human depravity, ambition, resilience, and vulnerability. It is surely one of the most important books of the year, and certainly among the most compelling.

Mark Bradford: You Don't Have to Tell Me Twice
By Jason DrillMAY 2023 | ArtSeen
For his first New York solo exhibition since 2015, Los Angeles-based artist Mark Bradford interlaces urgent themes of migration, isolation, and vulnerability with an uncompromising tenacity that breathes through monumental scale and unruly material.
Alexis Rockman: Melancolia
By Jonathan GoodmanJUNE 2023 | ArtSeen
Melancolia, Alexis Rockmans fifth show at Sperone Westwater, concerns a series of iceberg paintings on the first floor. On the second floor is a selection of slightly earlier work, concentrating on brilliantly detailed, surreal images of flora and fauna. Rockman has long been recognized for the attention he pays to nature, finding in it not only visual tropes of the most remarkable kind, but a cautionary tale emphasizing our ever-increasing vulnerability to damages brought about by climate change.
Cue Ball
By Bobby CraceAPRIL 2023 | Fiction
Were often told that successful fiction catalogs a protagonists emotional transformation, but what I find most appealing about Bobby Graces Cue Ball is that the two main characters, best friends who we follow from childhood to adulthood, resist change to the very end. As a child, Rory moves from Ireland to Arkansas and grows up feeling like an outsider. He latches onto BB, a troubled boy who idolizes his hustler father. When BBs father abandons him, he decides to follow in his footsteps and leave town too, even though Rory is certain that his friend will meet a terrible fate. Over several decades, we watch the boys' physical transformations, but despite BBs determination to destroy himself and his friendship, Rorys love for him persists. Ultimately, Cue Ball is a story about devotion and vulnerability, about making a home in people instead of places, and accepting that some people cannot be changed, but deciding to love them anyway.